10 Groups Oppose REGROW Bill
A coalition of 10 patient advocacy and research groups, including the Cystic Fibrosis, Muscular Dystrophy and National Patient Advocate foundations, the National MS Society, and the National Organization for Rare Disorders, say they oppose provisions in the Reliable and Effective Growth for Regenerative Health Options that Improve Wellness (REGROW Act). In a recent letter to the bill’s sponsor, Sen Mark Kirk (R-IL), the groups say that while they applaud his recognition of the cell and gene therapy and regenerative medicine sector’s therapeutic promise for patients with unmet medical needs, they are concerned that the legislation as drafted could compromise patient safety.
The letter says problems could arise because the bill would allow “conditional approval” for products that only show “preliminary clinical evidence of safety” in Phase 1 or 2 trials. “We are troubled,” the groups say, “that these provisions establish a new approval standard that is potentially lower than existing standards. By allowing products to be marketed as approved therapies, this implies to patients a high level of approval which is not warranted given the current requirements in the bill. We believe this legislation may result in grave consequences for patients.”
The groups say they also are concerned that the bill contains provisions that would make it difficult for FDA to withdraw such products from the market if it found safety problems.
“There exist several pathways to get critical treatments to patients quickly while maintaining strong FDA safety and efficacy standards,” the groups conclude. “These programs are aimed at unmet needs for serious life-threatening diseases that currently have no adequate approved treatment options. Consequently, we cannot support the REGROW Act in its current form.”