AdvaMed Backs Coverage of all IDE Trials

Share

Commenting on an FDA draft guidance on categorization of investigational device exemption (IDE) devices to assist the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) with coverage decisions, AdvaMed says it supports CMS coverage of all IDE trials. The comment letter says that in recent years CMS declined to cover only 3% of IDEs (non-coverage of both routine patient care costs and the investigational device).

The letter notes that trials are considered to be either Category A or Category B, and it supports the guidance policy clarification that IDEs may transition between the two categories. CMS covers device costs as well as routine patient care costs for Category B studies, AdvaMed says, but only routine patient care costs associated with Category A studies. To facilitate changing a Category A IDE to Category B, the trade group urges FDA to clarify in the final guidance the broad range of data sponsors can rely on to request a change of IDE category, including peer-reviewed studies, pre-market or post-market non-U.S. data on the same or similar device types, additional non-clinical data on the same or a similar device, and commercialization of a similar device type of preliminary clinical data on the device.

 

The 510(k) Coalition says it supports many of the ideas in the draft and the clarity it strives to offer. To increase the document’s usefulness, the coalition recommends adding links to documents referenced in the guidance. The coalition says the guidance does not clarify the process for switching an IDE from Category A to Category B and recommends that it address issues such as timelines on decisions for changing categories and the process a sponsor should follow in making such a request. It calls on FDA to ensure that the clinical trial sponsor is involved in the information collection and decision process.

Read more