Advisors Asked for ProSense Benefits, Risks

Share

FDA is asking members of its General and Plastic Surgery Advisory Committee to comment on the risks and benefits of IceCure Medical’s ProSense cryoblation system intended to be used in patients with early-stage, low-risk breast cancer as an alternative to breast-conserving surgery (lumpectomy). A briefing paper distributed in advance of the 11/7 committee meeting says ProSense offers a minimally invasive method of ablating localized breast tumors … in early-stage, low-risk breast cancer patients. “The treatment can be performed under local anesthesia as an alternative to the standard of care lumpectomy,” it says.

Advisory committee members were asked to comment on these questions:

  • the strengths and limitations of standard-of-care imaging technology to accurately characterize tumor size and extent before surgery or cryoblation treatment in early-stage, low-risk breast cancer patients;
  • the strengths and limitations of the single-arm, nonrandomized study design using a literature-derived performance goal for the primary endpoint;
  • the strengths and limitations of each analysis population and subpopulation for determining the benefit versus risk of the ProSense system for the proposed indication for use;
  • the overall significance of the effectiveness results in the study compared to the systematic literature review and meta-estimate results;
  • how the safety results inform the benefit and risk of the ProSense system;
  • the quality of life benefits of surgery avoidance relative to the quality of life risks of breast cancer recurrence for the intended patient population; and
  • the overall benefit/risk profile of the device for the proposed indication for use in the treatment of early-stage, low-risk breast cancer in lieu of lumpectomy.

Read more