China Stricter than U.S. in Cancer Drug Approvals: Study

Share

Researchers at China’s Capital Medical University say that compared to the U.S., China appears to take a more stringent regulation toward using surrogate endpoint response rate (RR) data to support cancer drug approvals. In an open-access Cancer Medicine article, the researchers discuss their analysis of all cancer drug-indication pairs based on RR in the U.S. and China to 12/2023.

The study reviewed nearly 350 RR-supported approvals of cancer drug indications, including 249 indications for 137 drugs in the U.S. and 98 indications for 68 drugs in China.

The researchers list these findings:

  • compared to the U.S., China appears to take a more stringent regulation toward using RR data to support drug approvals.
  • compared to the U.S., China’s regulation tends to require higher RR magnitude to support approval; and
  • the proportion of accelerated approval withdrawals in China was only 1%, while it was 10.4% in the U.S.

“Since surrogate endpoint does not mean an extension of survival and approval is influenced by regulatory authorities and policy experts,” the article concludes, “these authorities and experts in both countries may require considering a balance between quantity and quality when relying on surrogate endpoints as evidence.”

Read more