Device Alternate Reports ‘Inappropriate, Unfair’: Zuckerman

Share

National Center for Health Research president Diana Zuckerman says an FDA decision to allow some medical device manufacturers to submit summary reports of adverse events through a hidden Alternate Summary Reporting database was “very inappropriate and unfair to patients and physicians.” As reported online by Cancer Therapy Advisor, Zuckerman said FDA’s position that it implemented the alternate reporting program for adverse events that were already well known does not hold up.

“The justification does not make sense,” she said. “Because while it would make sense to say that FDA thought having summary information would be less burdensome for everyone, including FDA, that doesn’t explain why the information was also not public.”

Former FDAer David Gortler told the online service that he wished FDA had made the hidden reports public sooner.

Cancer Therapy Advisor says the breast implant data from the file that FDA has now published includes more than 4,000 events related to Allergen implants, more than 2,440 events for Mentor products, and more than 140 events linked to Sientra implants.

Zuckerman said that although patients and doctors know that adverse events happen, understanding how frequently they occur is important. “Having that information public is the only way that patients, doctors, or researchers are able to gather information about how often this happens,” she said. “…The bottom line is, the more information we have about medical devices, the more we as health professionals, or we as patients, can make informed decisions.”

Read more