FDA Policymaking May Return to Normalcy: Former FDAers
Speaking at the BIO 2026 convention, a panel of former FDA regulators praised the agency’s announcement of a pending IND pilot program as the potential start of a return to normalcy in policy making. The fact that the pilot was announced in an agency statement and solicited stakeholder feedback was praised by the panelists as a step away from the situation under former FDA commissioner Marty Makary, in which policy was announced in news releases, journal articles, and social media.
A BioSpace report on the panel discussion says Eva Temkin, formerly in the Chief Counsel’s Office and the Office of New Drugs, described a “callous disregard for policymaking in an open and transparent way.” She said the decision to post complete response letters was an example of a change that was dropped under the guise of transparency, but without engaging relevant stakeholders or fully explaining the rationale behind the decision.
Former FDAer Ritu Nalubola said she found it “shocking” to see policy pronouncements in social media posts and journal articles. She added that things became even more confusing when Makary and the CBER and CDER directors left the agency. “If the policy was announced in a journal article by two individuals who are no longer at the agency, what does that mean?” she asked. “Is it, in fact, FDA policy? Are reviewers in fact implementing that policy?”
With the IND pilot announcement and other recent guidances, she said, “It was heartwarming to see that FDA is coming back, maybe turning around, to establishing policy in a way that it’s supposed to.”