Lawmakers Press FDA on Covid-19 Test Accuracy
Just how accurate are the Covid-19 diagnostic tests? That’s a question two House lawmakers are asking FDA to provide information on in the wake of testing failures earlier this year involving Centers for Disease Control test kits.
A 4/9 letter from U.S. reps. Lloyd Doggett (D-TX) and Rosa DeLauro (D-CT) requests information about tests currently being used. They said that the “accuracy of recently approved tests is of particular concern because the original CDC test kits, which arrived at public health labs in early February, were flawed, indicating coronavirus in samples which did not contain the virus. Despite clear evidence that the test was fatally flawed, the Administration continued to rely on that inaccurate test for three weeks. This troubling and unjustified delay contributed greatly to the spread of the novel coronavirus in February and March, when those who were infected were not accurately identified and quarantined.”
The letter says that FDA’s ongoing authorization of new tests to “fill the serious gap caused by the Administration’s failure to provide adequate testing raises continued questions. Both a 3/11 study in the Journal of the American Medical Association and the United Kingdom Centre on Evidence-Based Medicine have questioned the accuracy of COVID-19 tests.” The lawmakers note that some physicians are still recommending the quarantine of patients with negative test results because they lack confidence in the tests.
The lawmakers are requesting an update on the current status of information provided to FDA about the accuracy of the COVID-19 tests, including:
* A list of laboratories that have submitted accuracy (sensitivity and specificity) information to the agency
* All information FDA has received from non-laboratory sources regarding the specificity and sensitivity of Covid-19 tests, or any concerns regarding the accuracy of the tests.
* A list of actions the agency has taken in response to performance data submitted, as required by any emergency use authorization