Panel Backs Pfizer’s RSV Vaccine
FDA’s Vaccines and Related Biological Products Advisory Committee 5/18 voted 14-0 that a Pfizer BLA demonstrated effectiveness for its Abrysvo (RSVpreF) vaccine for preventing respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) in infants from birth through six months by active immunization of pregnant individuals. A separate vote of 10-4 found that the data supported the safety of the vaccine.
In a briefing document released in advance of the committee meeting, agency reviewers said that vaccine efficacy for preventing severe RSV within 90 days after birth was 81.8%, with six cases in the vaccine group and 33 cases in the placebo group. Vaccine efficacy within 180 days after birth was 69.4%, with 19 cases in the vaccine group and 62 cases in the placebo group. Regarding safety, premature births were reported in 5.7% of infants in the vaccine group compared with 4.7% in the placebo group. Agency reviewers said this was a numerical imbalance and “not statistically significant.”
In voting no on the safety question, Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia professor Paul Offit said there were not enough safety data on premature births. “If you’re, in any sense, risking premature births with this vaccine, then I think there will be a big price to pay, and so I guess I just don’t feel we have enough data to be reassured, so that’s why I voted no,” he said after voting.
Scientific advisor and respiratory diseases consultant Daniel Feikin said he was concerned about the preterm birth imbalance but he voted yes because he was not convinced that there’s a clear causal relationship. “I’m still struck by the fact that this study was done in the setting of a pandemic … when so many things were different, and that this signal was not seen in high income countries,” he said. “And the key will be doing really good post marketing surveillance.”