Panel Views Asked on Shield Colorectal Cancer Screen

Share

Members of the FDA Molecular and Genetics Panel of the Medical Devices Advisory Panel will be asked to vote 5/23 on the safety and effectiveness of the Guardant Health Shield blood-based colorectal cancer screening test. An agency executive summary distributed in advance of the meeting says Shield is a “qualitative in vitro diagnostic test intended to detect colorectal cancer-derived alterations in cell-free DNA plasma isolated from the whole blood collected in the Guardant blood collection tubes for individuals at average risk of the disease, age 45 years and older.”

The summary says Shield’s performance has been established in a prospectively designed, blinded, cross-sectional study. Its programmatic sensitivity for non-inferiority or superiority as compared to other recommended screening methods for colorectal cancer has not been established, it says.

“The risk of the Guardant blood-based test for advanced adenomas is that the test will fail to detect a patient with advanced adenoma which can later become neoplastic, losing the opportunity to prevent or prolong the onset of colorectal cancer,” the summary says. “The benefit of the Guardant test is that it may increase compliance with colorectal cancer screening and detect earlier stage colorectal cancer, which may potentially cure the patient and also potentially prolong survival when treated.”

Panel members are asked to discuss the appropriate patient populations for the test and whether the clinical performance supports its use as a primary screening option or as more appropriate for specific populations, such as those who decline other screening tests.

The panel members will vote on whether there is reasonable assurance that Shield is safe and effective for its proposed indications for use and whether its benefits outweigh its risks for the proposed indications.

Read more