Pazdur Mulls Accelerated Approval International Harmonization
FDA is considering changes to its accelerated approval program, such as international harmonization efforts to “strengthen this approval pathway by considering the differences between expedited programs, including recent innovation by international [regulatory health agencies] RHAs,” according to Oncology Center of Excellence director Richard Pazdur and two other CDER officials.
Writing in a 1/20 JAMA opinion piece, the FDA officials seem interested in the expiry periods (one or two years) that certain RHAs attach to their expedited approvals. For example, in the EU and UK, a “conditional marketing authorization (CMA)” expires yearly and must be renewed with an application and interim report on outstanding obligations submitted at least six months before expiration.
Pazdur et al note that the evaluation of each renewal application includes a risk-benefit assessment, and a review of the time frame for completing confirmatory obligations determined at the time of the CMA. The mean time from granting CMA until conversion to a standard marketing authorization in the EU is 3.5 years.
“The expiry periods for conditional and provisional approval programs place the onus of timely completion of confirmatory trials and verification of benefit on the applicant in the EU, UK, Switzerland, and Australia,” the authors write. This contrasts with expedited programs elsewhere that place responsibility on the regulatory agency, like FDA, to initiate a resource-intensive withdrawal process. “Overall, these time-limited approaches may limit public exposure to stale claims of effectiveness that cannot be expeditiously substantiated,” they contend. “Conversely, as reasonable trial completion times are often indication specific, flexibility may be necessary in implementing such postmarketing time limits.”