Petition Against BD’s Breast Reconstruction Device

Share

Former Becton Dickinson (BD) medical director Hooman Noorchashm has petitioned FDA to “scrutinize” the company’s 2017 510(k) clearance for the GalaForm 3D due to label misrepresentations and “fraud on FDA.” Noorchashm’s petition alleges that BD “deliberately failed to reveal its true design to market and distribute the device primarily as an ‘internal bra’ for breast reconstruction surgeries. Furthermore, the manufacturer also deliberately or negligently failed to inform FDA or consumers/patients about a potential oncogenic safety concern regarding the ‘P4HB’ material used to manufacture its GalaFlex products.”

Cardiac surgeon Noorchashm is best known to FDA for his opposition to power morcellation. He previously alleged his BD employment was terminated in 8/2022 after he continually objected to the company’s alleged practice of not reporting device defects to the agency.

In the petition, Noorchashm argues that despite BD’s intentional design of the mesh product for breast reconstruction, “nowhere in the 510(k) application did the … applicant make mention of its very specific intent to target GalaGlex 3DR to the tightly regulated clinical breast surgery space.”

Additionally, the petition asserts that because BD knew the device would be used in breast surgeries and it has “aggressively” promoted it off-label, then the company should have sought an expanded label for such use.

Read more