Probe 2 ‘Unethical’ Minnesota Tests: Public Citizen

Share

Public Citizen says FDA and the HHS Office for Human Research Protections (OHRP) should immediately investigate two prospective clinical trials in Minnesota that involved testing the general anesthetic ketamine and powerful sedatives on patients without their consent. The advocacy group was joined by 64 doctors, bioethicists, and academics in the call for FDA/OHRP action, according to a Public Citizen news release (contains link to letter to FDA and OHRP).

The group says that researchers at Hennepin County Medical Center failed to obtain consent from test subjects for high-risk clinical trials involving testing the safety and effectiveness of the ketamine compound compared with other potent sedative drugs for managing pre-hospital agitation. The drugs were injected into the subjects by Hennepin County emergency medical system paramedics, Public Citizen says.

The trials were first reported by the Minneapolis Star Tribune and described in the journal Clinical Toxicology. “The use of ketamine in particular made these experiments high-risk,” says Public Citizen Health Research Group director Michael Carome. “Ketamine can cause severe airway obstruction, interfering with breathing.”

The hospital has aggressively defended the trials, Public Citizen says, and has misrepresented them as “observational studies.”

Carome says the “regulatory and ethical lapses in the oversight and conduct of these trials reflect colossal failures of the Hennepin County Medical Center’s human subjects protection program. The failures extended from the researchers to the institutional review board that approved the trials to senior institutional officials. FDA and OHRP must promptly find out whether there are other trials ongoing at this medical center with similar lapses.”

Read more